Buying Off-Plan vs. Existing Construction in Cuenca: A Broker-Lawyer's Guide to Protecting Your Investment

As a Real Estate Broker and Lawyer practicing in Cuenca, my singular focus is the ironclad protection of my expat clients' investments. The dream of a home in this city is achievable, but the path is paved with unique legal and financial intricacies. This guide dissects the two primary routes to property ownership here: purchasing "off-plan" from a developer versus buying an existing home. The legal frameworks are distinct, and understanding them is the first line of defense for your capital.

The Allure and Legal Peril of Off-Plan Construction

Purchasing a property before it's built – "off-plan" or en planos – attracts buyers with modern designs, customization options, and often, a lower entry price. Developers structure payments over the construction period, which can be financially appealing. However, this path carries significant risks that demand rigorous legal oversight.

Legal and Financial Safeguards for Off-Plan Purchases

The cornerstone of an off-plan purchase is the Promesa de Compraventa (Promise to Purchase Agreement). This is not a simple reservation form; it is a binding legal contract that must be notarized to be enforceable. I cannot overstate this: this document, reviewed by your own independent attorney, is your most critical shield.

Key Legal and Financial Considerations for Off-Plan:

1. The Promesa de Compraventa: This contract must meticulously detail every aspect of the transaction.

   • Precise Property Definition: It must reference architectural plans (planos), a detailed list of finishes (memoria de acabados), exact square meterage of private and communal areas, and the specific parking space and storage unit (bodega) assigned.
   • Penalty Clauses: What are the specific, daily financial penalties if the developer fails to meet the delivery date? Ecuadorian law allows for these clauses, and a strong Promesa will include them to protect you from indefinite delays.
   • Payment Structure & Guarantees: Payments should be tied to verified construction milestones. Hyper-Specific Detail #1: The gold standard for financial safety is a developer who uses a fideicomiso (a legally established trust). In this structure, your payments go to a neutral, third-party trust administrator, not directly to the developer. Funds are only released to the developer upon completion of contractually defined construction phases, providing a powerful layer of protection against misuse of funds or developer bankruptcy. Insist on it if possible.

2. Developer Due Diligence: We conduct a deep dive into the developer's legal and financial health. This includes verifying their tax ID (RUC), their legal registration with the Superintendencia de Compañías, and a history of successfully completed and legally registered projects. We also check for any ongoing litigation against the developer.

3. The Final Deed (Escritura Pública): Ownership is not transferred until the building is 100% complete, has received all municipal approvals, including the final inspection (Inspección Final) and fire department certificate, and has been officially registered under the Horizontal Property regime (Propiedad Horizontal). Only then can the final Escritura Pública (Public Deed of Sale) be signed and registered in your name at the Registro de la Propiedad (Property Registry).

Risks Associated with Off-Plan Purchases:

• Construction Delays: These are common. A well-drafted contract with penalties mitigates the financial impact.
• Quality Discrepancies: The final product may not match the showroom model. The memoria de acabados annexed to your Promesa is your legal recourse.
• Developer Insolvency: The greatest risk. A fideicomiso is the best structural protection against losing your entire investment if the developer fails.

The Security and Scrutiny of Existing Construction

Buying an existing property offers the distinct advantage of certainty. You can physically inspect, assess, and occupy the home immediately. However, the property comes with a history that must be exhaustively investigated.

Legal and Financial Safeguards for Existing Construction

Here, the due diligence process is an intense forensic examination of the property's legal and financial history. There is no substitute for this.

Key Legal and Financial Considerations for Existing Construction:

1. The Non-Negotiable Title Investigation:

   • Hyper-Specific Detail #2: Before any money changes hands, we secure a Certificado de Gravamen Actualizado directly from the Registro de la Propiedad. This is the single most important document in a resale transaction. It is an official certificate that reveals if the property has any liens, mortgages, lawsuits, or legal prohibitions against its sale. A certificate provided by the seller is insufficient; we pull a fresh one, dated within days of the closing, to ensure no last-minute encumbrances have been placed on the title.
   • We trace the property's ownership history (estudio de títulos) back at least 20 years to confirm an unbroken and legal chain of title.

2. Municipal and Tax Clearance: We obtain certificates from the Cuenca municipality confirming that all property taxes (Impuesto Predial) and related contributions are paid in full. Any outstanding municipal debt is attached to the property, not the previous owner, and will become your liability.

3. Distinguishing Property Types:

   • Hyper-Specific Detail #3: Ecuador legally distinguishes between standalone property (cuerpo cierto) and property under the Horizontal Property regime (Propiedad Horizontal), which applies to apartments and condos. For a Propiedad Horizontal purchase, it is mandatory to obtain a certificate from the building administrator confirming that the seller is current on all HOA fees (alícuotas). Unpaid fees can become a lien against the property.

4. The Transfer Process and Costs:

   • The sale is finalized with an Escritura Pública signed before a Notario (Notary Public).
   • Hyper-Specific Detail #4: The buyer is responsible for paying the property transfer taxes. In Azuay province, the primary tax is the Alcabalas, which is currently calculated at approximately 1% of the sale price listed in the deed. There are also smaller provincial and registration fees. We provide our clients with a precise closing cost statement well in advance.

Risks Associated with Existing Construction:

• Hidden Defects: Structural, plumbing, or electrical issues. A thorough home inspection by a qualified architect or engineer is essential.
• Unregistered Additions: Many owners build additions or make renovations without proper municipal permits. This can create significant legal problems and fines when you later try to sell. We verify the constructed square footage against the registered property records.
• Boundary Disputes: For standalone homes, we recommend verifying the property lines described in the deed against a physical survey (levantamiento planimétrico).

Future-Proofing Your Investment: A Note on Capital Gains

Hyper-Specific Detail #5: When you eventually sell your Cuenca property, you will be subject to capital gains tax, known as plusvalía. Ecuador has two types: a municipal plusvalía tax and a national income tax on capital gains. The national tax is particularly relevant for expats. If you sell a property that is not your primary residence, the profit is taxed as occasional income. Understanding this future tax liability from the day you buy is part of a sound investment strategy.

⚠️ Broker-Lawyer's Warning: The Veto-Power Risk

The most catastrophic and entirely avoidable error an expat can make is rushing the due diligence process. I have seen investors lose everything by accepting a seller’s verbal assurances or an outdated Certificado de Gravamen. A lien can be placed on a property hours before closing. My non-negotiable policy is to pull a new, official Certificado de Gravamen on the morning of the closing. If it is not 100% clean, the transaction is stopped. There is no exception. The modest fee for thorough legal vetting is the best insurance policy you can buy against the total loss of your investment.

Navigating Your Cuenca Property Journey with Confidence

The choice between off-plan and existing construction is a choice between two different risk profiles. Off-plan requires you to place legally-secured trust in a developer's future performance. Existing construction requires you to forensically investigate a property's past.

In either scenario, proceeding without dual expertise in both the real estate market and Ecuadorian property law is an unnecessary gamble. My role is to serve as your advocate, meticulously scrutinizing every document, verifying every claim, and ensuring your dream of a home in Cuenca is built upon a foundation of absolute legal and financial security.

---

Ready to safeguard your Cuenca property investment? Schedule a property-risk consultation with me today.